Nevertheless, the government of Uzbekistan remains deeply authoritarian, according to observers. Backtracking on and slowdown in democratic reforms in the field of freedom of speech, and the hallmarks of nepotism cause special concern.
The level of freedom of speech in the country is still assessed as 'complicated' in the international rankings.
The Human Rights Watch
noted a significant backtrack of Uzbekistan on democratic reforms in its 2022 global report.
"Freedom of speech and the media experienced clear setbacks. […]Although media activity in Uzbekistan has increased considerably since 2016, there was a notable decline in respect for speech and media freedoms in 2021. Journalists faced harassment, prosecution, and assault. Defamation and insult remain criminal offenses, despite President Mirziyoyev's decriminalization pledge in 2020," according to the report.
In July 2022, Uzbek authorities suppressed protests in Karakalpakstan, which took place in Nukus because the authorities decided to make amendments about the deprivation of Karakalpakstan of its status of a sovereign republic.
The protests were suppressed by force and use of fire weapon. According to official data, 21 people died, including four officers of force authorities, 243 people were wounded.
Several dozens of citizens, mainly civil activists, journalists and human rights defenders, were sentenced to imprisonment on charges of incitement of interethnic hatred and calls for overthrow of the constitutional system.
Local and international human rights institutions
condemned Uzbekistan for excessive force used to disperse protesters and called on the Uzbek government to carry out a fair investigation and to hold accountable those responsible for the tragedy.
It should be noted that unlike the Karimov's regime, the current government showed humanism and willingness to a compromise. Citizens of Karakalpakstan managed to maintain their sovereignty. Some Karakalpakstan activists, who took part in protests, received suspended sentences.
Another sign of authoritarian political regime in Uzbekistan is the nepotism and concentration of rather significant key business assets in the hands of the incumbent president's family, and the political career of his daughter, Saida Mirziyoyeva.
In August 2023, President Mirziyoyev appointed his 38-year-old daughter Saida as the assistant of the leader of Uzbekistan, thus cancelling the posts of the head of the presidential administration and his/her deputies. In fact, she became the head of the presidential administration and the second person in his administration.
In July 2023, Radio Ozodlik and journalist Chris Rickleton published a major
investigation on how the family of the president of Uzbekistan built a business empire and had influence on all economic sectors of the country.
According to political analyst
Rafael Sattarov, attraction of foreign investments is necessary not only to attract money to the country and to develop entrepreneurship, but also to legalise and accumulate the capital of key elites of Uzbekistan and their children.
Mirziyoyev has unresolved major issues in the power system. Last winter, there was the energy crisis in Uzbekistan, and the national leadership failed the heating season.
Unlike Karimov, Mirziyoyev has made some efforts in liberalisation, but he still maintains great concentration of power within his family.
Once he came to power, people began to discuss Uzbekistan as an opening and reforming state. But it's obvious now that the country will fail to get rid of the administrative-command form of government in the foreseeable future, while all initiatives will still come from one person.
According to political analyst
Timur Umarov, some economic expectations have been met, but the political situation has changed little. Uzbekistan still faces problems on its path to a more democratic and open society in the future.
Experts still do not know how the transfer of power will occur in Uzbekistan and who will be the next president of the country.